New South Wales bill to expand Mount Pleasant coalmine raises corruption concerns

New South Wales bill to expand Mount Pleasant coalmine raises corruption concerns

A New South Wales government bill set to be debated this week would allow MACH Energy to increase coal production at the Mount Pleasant coalmine in the Hunter Valley. The proposal follows a High Court ruling that found the mine's expansion had been invalidly approved. The legislation has drawn criticism from anti-corruption campaigner Geoffrey Watson, who says it creates a serious corruption risk.

Advert for a company owned by the publisher of 360LiveNews.

Under the bill, production at the Muswellbrook site would rise by 32% to 16.5 million tonnes a year. The government has said the measure is needed to prevent 400 job losses at the mine before Christmas. Watson, a barrister and former counsel assisting the New South Wales Independent Commission Against Corruption, said a clause in the bill would give the resources minister unusually broad powers to override other state laws.

The disputed provision is known as a Henry VIII clause, a term used for laws that allow ministers to make regulations that can modify existing legislation. Watson said Clause 17 would explicitly place wide powers to make new laws, or repeal or modify existing ones, in the hands of one person, the mining minister, and for a single coal mine owner. He argued that concentrating that kind of authority in one office creates a serious corruption risk, particularly because the bill has been drafted for one private company.

The Greens and some crossbench members have also raised concerns about the clause. Watson said he did not impute bad faith to the current mining minister, but added that past experience in the state had shown not all ministers had acted free from improper motives. His comments add to scrutiny of the government's attempt to legislate around the court ruling and keep the project moving.

Amazon US (JB) - Kindle e-readers

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Mount Pleasant case sits at the intersection of energy policy, jobs and planning law in New South Wales. Coal remains a major part of the state's resources sector, and the Hunter Valley is one of its most significant mining regions. Any move to authorise a single project through bespoke legislation is likely to attract close attention from legal and political observers because of the precedent it may set.

The High Court decision has already forced the government to seek a legislative fix, rather than rely on the original approval process. That has sharpened debate over how far ministers should be able to intervene in planning and resources decisions. It also raises questions about the balance between protecting employment at the site and preserving safeguards against executive overreach.

Watson's analysis has placed the bill under a wider integrity lens, not just an economic one. His warning is likely to resonate because of his background with the state's anti-corruption watchdog and his role in public integrity work. The fact that the legislation is designed for one mine and one company is central to the criticism, as it suggests a highly targeted use of lawmaking power.

What remains unclear is whether the government will amend the bill in response to the concerns or press ahead unchanged. The immediate test will come during this week's parliamentary debate, where the clause's scope and the need for the legislation are expected to be examined closely. The outcome will determine whether the Mount Pleasant expansion can proceed and whether the state accepts a broader ministerial power to alter laws for a single project.

Amazon US (JB) - Best-selling tablets

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

360LiveNews 360LiveNews | 16 Nov 2026 14:37 LONDON
← Back to Homepage