US report warns AUKUS submarine sales to Australia would weaken fleet for years

US report warns AUKUS submarine sales to Australia would weaken fleet for years

A new analysis for the US Congress says transferring Virginia-class submarines to Australia under the AUKUS pact would reduce the number of attack submarines available to the US Navy for many years. The report also raises questions about whether Australian-controlled submarines could be used in a conflict involving China. It adds fresh scrutiny to one of the most significant defence arrangements between Washington and Canberra.

More from 360LiveNews Opinion

The Congressional Budget Office released the analysis on Friday morning, according to the supplied material. It says the US submarine industrial base is already struggling to meet Navy demand, and that increasing production to replace submarines sold to Australia would add to pressure on shipyards. The US Navy's latest shipbuilding plan does not include the AUKUS transfer in its forecasts, noting only in a footnote that any sale of Virginia-class submarines to Australia has not been factored in.

Under the first pillar of AUKUS, the US has agreed to sell between three and five in-service Virginia-class submarines to Australia, beginning in 2032. The report says that would diminish the US fleet for many years, even as the alliance with Australia is described as longstanding and robust. It also argues that Australian submarines, if based in the Western Pacific, could in theory respond more quickly to a conflict over Taiwan or other issues in the South China Sea.

The analysis matters because it goes to the balance between allied burden-sharing and US force readiness. AUKUS was designed to deepen defence cooperation among the US, Australia and the United Kingdom, with submarine transfer at the centre of the plan. But the report suggests the arrangement could create a capability gap for the US Navy at a time when submarine demand is already outpacing supply.

More from 360LiveNews Opinion

The report also highlights a legal and operational uncertainty: Australia would control its own submarines, and their participation in any particular conflict would not be guaranteed. That means the strategic value of the transfer may depend on circumstances that cannot be assumed in advance. The analysis therefore places a question mark over whether the deal would strengthen deterrence in a future confrontation with China, or instead leave the US with fewer boats available.

The supplied material does not say how the US Congress or the Biden administration will respond to the findings, and it does not provide any immediate policy change. It is also unclear whether the report will alter the timetable for the planned submarine sales. What remains to be watched is whether lawmakers use the analysis to press for changes to AUKUS implementation, shipbuilding plans, or the schedule for transferring the submarines.

360LiveNews 360LiveNews | 20 Nov 2026 00:29 LONDON
← Back to Homepage