Israel charges settler over killing of Palestinian activist in rare West Bank case
Israeli prosecutors have filed a rare indictment against settler Yinon Levy over the killing of Palestinian activist Odeh Hathaleen in the occupied West Bank. The charge, filed by Israel's Southern District Prosecutor's Office, accuses Levy of reckless manslaughter and also includes armed trespassing and malicious property damage. The case stems from a confrontation in Umm al-Khair in July 2025, where settlers were operating an excavator in the Palestinian village.
Sponsored
According to the indictment, Levy cocked his gun during the confrontation and fired in the direction of residents, hitting Hathaleen, before firing another shot into the air. Footage of the incident was widely shared online, and Levy has previously denied firing the shot that killed Hathaleen. In a letter seen by the Associated Press, Levy said he would fight for his innocence in court and argued that prosecutors should not penalise acts of self-defence.
His lawyer, Avichai Hajbi, told the agency the prosecution had made a mistaken decision. The indictment has drawn attention because Israeli rights group B'Tselem said it was the first time an Israeli had been indicted for killing a Palestinian in the West Bank for nearly three years. It also comes after the 7 October 2023 Hamas-led attack on southern Israel, which triggered the Gaza war and was followed by a rise in settler violence in the West Bank.
B'Tselem said at least 1,110 Palestinians and at least 41 Israelis have been killed in the West Bank since then, according to UN figures cited in the reporting. Hathaleen was linked to the Oscar-winning documentary No Other Land, which has helped make his killing a focal point for campaigners and rights groups. A lawyer for Hathaleen's family said they hoped the charges marked a turning point in the consequences settlers face for violence against Palestinians.
Sponsored
The case also sits within a wider debate over accountability in the occupied territory, where Palestinians and human rights groups have long accused Israeli authorities of failing to prosecute attacks by settlers and soldiers. The supplied material does not indicate a trial date or how the district court will handle the case. It is also unclear whether the prosecution will lead to a conviction, and the defence is expected to contest the charges.
The case is likely to remain under close scrutiny because it combines a rare criminal charge, disputed claims of self-defence and broader concerns about violence around Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank.
Israeli prosecutors have filed a rare indictment against settler Yinon Levi over the killing of Palestinian activist and teacher Awdah Hathaleen in the occupied West Bank. The charge, filed in an Israeli district court, accuses Levi of reckless manslaughter and also includes armed trespassing and malicious property damage. The case stems from a confrontation in the village of Umm al-Khair in July 2025.
Hathaleen, who was 31 and a father of three, was killed when settlers brought excavators into the village to level land for a new illegal outpost, according to the supplied reporting. Video from the scene, including footage said to have been filmed by Hathaleen himself, showed Levi firing shots towards a crowd. A separate analysis by the Palestinian rights group Al-Haq, published on the first anniversary of the killing, said video, testimony and geospatial evidence matched the fatal wound to Levi's handgun and found that none of the Palestinians present were armed.
Sponsored
The indictment is notable because Israeli human rights group Yesh Din said the last Israeli civilian indictment over the killing of a Palestinian in the West Bank was in 2019. Levi's lawyer has rejected the charges and said the defence will contest them in court. The case has also drawn attention because an ambulance trying to reach Hathaleen was reportedly blocked while Israeli soldiers and police looked on, according to the supplied material.
The killing has wider significance because it sits within a broader surge in settler violence in the West Bank since the Gaza war began in October 2023. The supplied reporting cites B'Tselem as saying at least 1,100 Palestinians, including 240 children, have been killed in the West Bank by settlers and soldiers since then. The indictment therefore lands in a highly sensitive legal and political environment, where accountability for violence in the occupied territory is closely watched by Palestinian communities, rights groups and foreign governments.
Hathaleen was also known for his work on the Oscar-winning documentary No Other Land and for hosting foreign activists in his home. That background has helped make his killing a focal point for campaigners who say violence against Palestinians in the West Bank is rarely punished. Levi was previously among settlers sanctioned by the United Kingdom and the European Union over violence against Palestinians, although the supplied material says United States sanctions were later lifted after Donald Trump returned to office in 2025.
What remains unclear is how the district court will handle the case and whether the prosecution will lead to a conviction. The defence has signalled it will challenge the indictment, and the supplied material does not indicate a trial date. The case is likely to remain under close scrutiny because it combines a rare criminal charge, disputed claims of self-defence and broader concerns about violence around Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank.
Sponsored
