Western powers condemn Israel's E1 West Bank settlement plan
Major Western powers and Canada have condemned Israel's decision to open construction tenders for the E1 settlement project in the occupied West Bank. The move concerns a strategically sensitive area east of Jerusalem, near the settlement of Ma'ale Adumim, and has triggered a fresh diplomatic backlash. Critics say the plan would make a future Palestinian state harder to establish and deepen tensions in the territory.
Sponsored
In a joint statement, France, Italy, the United Kingdom, Germany and Canada called the decision unacceptable and urged Israel to retract the plans immediately. The countries said the announcement came at a time of grave instability in the West Bank, citing unprecedented violence by settlers against civilians and serious restrictions on the Palestinian economy. They also warned that the project would further undermine prospects for peace and Israel's international standing.
The tender covers 1,234 homes out of 3,401 housing units approved by the Israeli government last August, according to the supplied reports. The E1 area spans about 12 square kilometres between East Jerusalem and Ma'ale Adumim. The project has long been viewed as highly contentious because it would effectively break the West Bank in two and isolate East Jerusalem from surrounding Palestinian areas.
The latest condemnation adds to long-running international opposition to settlement expansion in occupied territory. Under international law, settlements are considered illegal, and successive Israeli governments have faced pressure to avoid construction in E1 because of its impact on the territorial contiguity of a future Palestinian state. The issue has remained politically sensitive for decades, but it has gained renewed urgency amid the war between Israel and Hamas and the wider deterioration in the West Bank.
Sponsored
The supplied material says the Israeli government first announced plans to start construction in January this year, before authorities opened bidding this week. It also notes that the plans had been held back for years under international pressure. One Israeli minister previously said the project would "bury" the idea of a Palestinian state, while Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich said at the time of the plans' unveiling that the idea of a Palestinian state was "being erased".
The diplomatic response has also involved direct exchanges between officials. UK Foreign Secretary David Miliband said he delivered the joint message to his Israeli counterpart, Gideon Saar, who then rejected the criticism outright and objected to what he called the patronising tone of the remarks. In a separate statement, the UN secretary general said the E1 plan posed an existential threat to a contiguous Palestinian state, underscoring the wider international concern around the project.
The timing of the tender is also politically significant inside Israel. The deadline for bids is 19 October, only days before the country's general election on 27 October, which could make the project harder for any future government to reverse. The reports say the plan would replace a local Bedouin community and add new housing and road infrastructure in the area.
That combination of land use, displacement concerns and electoral timing has made the issue especially sensitive. What remains unclear is how far the tender process will advance and whether legal or political challenges will alter the timetable. Bedouin Palestinians living in the area and Israeli peace groups have already mounted a court challenge, according to the supplied reports.
Sponsored
The next key point to watch is whether Israel proceeds with the bids as planned or faces further pressure from allies and international institutions to halt the project.
Sponsored
