US pitches NATO-like security guarantees for post-war Ukraine after Berlin talks
Jared Kushner said Russia is "comfortable" with NATO-like security guarantees for post-war Ukraine after a meeting in Berlin with European leaders, in a fresh sign of movement in the diplomacy around the war. The comments came as the United States continued to press a plan for Ukraine's future security once the fighting ends. Russian officials quickly pushed back, saying any form of "quasi membership" for Kyiv in the Western military alliance would be unacceptable.
More from 360LiveNews Opinion
Kushner made the remarks at a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing in Germany's capital, where he and fellow US envoy Steve Witkoff sought to reassure European leaders about Washington's approach. He said President Donald Trump wanted to make a deal with Europe "by his side", and said discussions in Shenzhen with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin had also touched on ending the war. French President Emmanuel Macron responded by saying Ukraine's NATO membership should be considered again, prompting a sharp rejection from Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov.
The exchange matters because it goes to the core of any post-war settlement: what security arrangement could deter renewed Russian attacks without formally bringing Ukraine into NATO. Ukraine applied to join the alliance in September 2022, and the Kremlin has repeatedly warned that membership would trigger a harsh response. NATO's Article 5, which treats an attack on one member as an attack on all, remains the benchmark against which any alternative guarantee is being judged.
The Berlin talks also underline the continuing effort by European governments to avoid being sidelined in negotiations over Ukraine. European leaders have said any peace process that excludes them would be unstable, while Kyiv has long argued that credible security guarantees are essential to any durable agreement. The issue has become more urgent as the war approaches its fifth year and as major-power diplomacy has accelerated without a clear, agreed framework.
More from 360LiveNews Opinion
The latest comments follow a period of heightened diplomatic activity, including the Shenzhen summit involving Trump, Xi and Putin, which added to European concern that decisions about Ukraine could be shaped elsewhere. In Berlin, the Coalition of the Willing was used as a forum for allies to coordinate their position and press for a role in any future talks. Macron's intervention showed that some European leaders still see NATO itself as the most credible long-term answer, even if that remains politically difficult.
Russia's response suggests that any proposal resembling NATO membership, even indirectly, will remain highly contested. Ryabkov's rejection of "quasi membership" indicates Moscow is drawing a line against arrangements that would give Ukraine protections similar to those of alliance members. That leaves open the question of whether a separate security pact, backed by the United States and European partners, could be made strong enough to satisfy Kyiv and deter Moscow.
What remains unclear is whether Kushner's comments reflect a real shift in Russia's position or a US interpretation of the talks in Berlin and Shenzhen. It is also not yet clear what form any guarantee would take, who would enforce it, or whether European governments would accept a model short of full NATO membership. The next stage to watch is whether the Berlin discussions lead to a concrete negotiating format or whether the gap between Moscow, Kyiv and Europe remains too wide to bridge.
European leaders meeting in Berlin said they were ready to enter negotiations with Russia on ending the war in Ukraine, while insisting that Europe and Kyiv must be part of any deal. The talks brought together members of the Coalition of the Willing in the German capital only hours after the three-way summit in Shenzhen between Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said any peace process that excluded Europe would fail, and British Prime Minister Andy Burnham said Europe had a clear and united negotiating position.
Advert for a company owned by the publisher of 360LiveNews.
The Berlin meeting also drew in US representatives, including Jared Kushner, who said Trump wanted to make a deal with Russia "with Europe by his side". Kushner said Russia believed Europe at the table would be essential to ending the war, while Putin said Moscow was not opposed in principle to European participation but wanted to know what Europe would bring to the talks. Putin also said Russia had invited Europeans to Moscow through diplomatic channels to set out their positions before deciding the format of further dialogue with Ukraine.
The exchange underlined a continuing dispute over who should shape any future settlement. European leaders have been angered by what they see as being sidelined in stop-start US-led contacts with Russia and Ukraine, while Kyiv has long sought security guarantees that would make any agreement more durable. Macron said the priority was to strengthen Ukraine's defences, including anti-missile systems and interceptors, and he raised the question of Ukraine's accession to Nato again in response to what he described as the hard line of the Russian position.
The Berlin gathering matters because it comes at a sensitive point in the wider diplomacy around the war. The conflict has become not only a battlefield struggle but also a contest over the shape of any post-war security order in Europe. For European governments, the concern is that a settlement negotiated without them could leave the continent exposed to future instability, while for Ukraine the issue is whether any peace arrangement would include credible guarantees against renewed attack.
The meeting also reflected the broader significance of the Shenzhen summit, where Trump, Putin and Xi discussed Ukraine and other security issues without explicit mention of the country in their joint declaration. That omission sharpened European concerns that major-power diplomacy could proceed without the direct involvement of those most affected. Merz described the Shenzhen meeting as a "photo op" and said peace talks could only succeed with Ukraine and Europe involved.
The Coalition of the Willing has been used as a forum for Ukraine's allies to coordinate their position, and the Berlin session was presented as a show of unity after months of uncertainty over the direction of negotiations. Burnham said Europe was ready to enter talks, but stressed that a peace agreement between Ukraine and Russia must come first. He also welcomed the US presence in Berlin, saying it added momentum to efforts to end the war.
What remains unclear is how quickly the stated willingness to negotiate can be turned into a formal process, and whether Russia will accept a format that gives Europe a direct role. It is also not yet clear whether the invitation for Europeans to set out their positions in Moscow will lead to a concrete meeting or remain a diplomatic signal. The next stage to watch is whether Ukraine, Europe, the United States and Russia can be brought into the same framework, or whether the divisions exposed in Berlin will continue to slow progress.
European leaders meeting in Berlin have rejected any attempt to recreate a Yalta-style division of Europe after the trilateral talks between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen. The response came at a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing hosted by German Chancellor Friedrich Merz, only hours after the three leaders issued a joint declaration on peace that did not mention Ukraine. The Berlin gathering was presented by participants as a direct rebuttal to the idea that Europe's future could be decided without Europeans or Ukrainians at the table.
Merz said a Yalta format would not bring peace and warned that Europe would not allow itself to be "parcelled up" again. He said the Berlin meeting was significant for Europe's security and handed the more than 40 delegations present a piece of the Berlin Wall, describing it as a reminder of what Yalta represented. French President Emmanuel Macron said the Shenzhen declaration did not amount to a reorganisation of the world and argued that any negotiations to end the war must include Ukraine, Europe, the United States and Russia together.
The leaders also stressed that the war in Ukraine cannot be settled over the heads of those directly affected. British Prime Minister Andy Burnham said there is no decision about Ukraine without Ukraine in the room and no decision about European security without Europe represented. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said the Berlin meeting showed Russia had failed to divide European allies.
The leaders agreed that Europe should now move toward face-to-face negotiations with Russia, a step that has not yet taken place in the process. The exchange matters because it touches the wider question of how any future peace framework for Ukraine would be shaped. The 1945 Yalta Conference, which set out post-war spheres of influence in Europe, remains a powerful reference point in European diplomacy and security debates.
By invoking it, the Berlin leaders signalled concern that major-power talks could sideline European interests at a moment when the war in Ukraine continues and strategic tensions remain high. The Berlin meeting also reflects the broader diplomatic backdrop created by the Shenzhen summit, where the three leaders discussed Ukraine and other security issues but did not include explicit language on the country in their declaration. That omission sharpened European concerns that any emerging peace process could be defined by outside powers.
The Coalition of the Willing, which brings together Kyiv's allies, used the Berlin session to present a common position on representation and security. What remains unclear is how quickly Europe's stated intention to engage Russia directly can be turned into a formal negotiating format. It is also not yet known whether the Berlin position will influence any follow-up from the Shenzhen talks or lead to a broader peace track.
The next point to watch is whether Ukraine, Europe, the United States and Russia can be brought into the same process, or whether the diplomatic divide exposed in Berlin will deepen further.
#Ukraine #Russia #NATO #JaredKushner #Berlin #EmmanuelMacron #SergeiRyabkov #securityguarantees