Berlin Ukraine talks shift toward NATO debate and air defence support
French President Emmanuel Macron said Ukraine's NATO accession question should be reopened, arguing that the issue had been set aside in early 2022 in a very different security context. He made the remarks after a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing in Berlin, which France and the United Kingdom co-chaired. Macron also urged Kyiv's allies to do the maximum to provide the air defence systems Ukraine needs.
Advert for a company owned by the publisher of 360LiveNews.
His comments came as European leaders in Berlin continued discussions on security guarantees and the shape of any future settlement with Russia. Macron said the question of Ukraine's long-term security matters for Europe as well as for Kyiv, adding that a well-equipped Ukrainian army would have implications for the continent's defence environment after the war. The remarks followed recent US-mediated peace talks in Abu Dhabi, where Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said negotiators had floated the idea of Ukraine withdrawing from the eastern Donbas region in exchange for NATO membership.
The debate is significant because Western allies ruled out short-term NATO membership for Ukraine after Russia's full-scale invasion in 2022, fearing a direct confrontation under Article 5. Macron's intervention suggests that some European leaders are now revisiting that position as part of wider talks on guarantees, deterrence and the post-war balance of power. Zelenskyy has said he is not prepared to concede territory, but that he would consult Ukrainian society if Western countries set out firm assurances.
Poland's deputy foreign minister has said a peace deal to end Russia's war in Ukraine is not workable without Europe taking part, as allied discussions in Berlin turn toward more concrete security guarantees. Ignacy Niemczycki said Europe's involvement was a practical necessity, not just a diplomatic preference, and argued that nothing about the continent's security architecture should be decided without European input. His comments came as the Coalition of the Willing met in Berlin to discuss post-war arrangements for Ukraine.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Niemczycki said the group's talks were evolving toward a more concrete military commitment, including the question of whether any settlement would need to be enforced. He said discussions on military enforcement were "evolving", indicating that allies are moving beyond broad political support and into the details of how a future agreement might be upheld. He also said the outcome would have direct consequences for Poland's own national security, given the risk of Russia moving closer to its borders.
The remarks add to a wider European debate over how to deter renewed Russian aggression if a peace deal is reached. European governments have been trying to define what security guarantees for Ukraine would look like in practice, including who would provide them and how they would be backed. The Berlin meeting suggests those talks are now focusing less on general principles and more on the mechanics of enforcement, which could shape the credibility of any future settlement.
The issue matters because the war in Ukraine has become a central test of Europe's security posture and its ability to act collectively. Poland, which borders both Ukraine and Russia's ally Belarus, has repeatedly framed the conflict as a direct threat to its own defence environment. That makes Warsaw one of the more vocal supporters of strong guarantees for Kyiv, especially if any agreement is meant to prevent a renewed Russian advance after hostilities stop.
The Coalition of the Willing has been working on post-war security guarantees for Ukraine, and the Berlin gathering appears to be part of that effort. The latest comments suggest the group is grappling with the practical question of whether allies would merely support a ceasefire or play a more active role in enforcing it. That distinction is likely to remain central to negotiations, because it affects both the credibility of any deal and the level of commitment required from European states.
More from 360LiveNews Opinion
What remains unclear is how far the coalition is prepared to go, and whether its members can agree on a common military role. It is also not clear what form any future guarantees would take or how they would be linked to broader peace talks. The next developments to watch are whether the Berlin discussions produce a more defined framework and whether European governments can turn political backing for Ukraine into a concrete security plan.
European, US and Ukrainian officials are pushing to move the Ukraine peace process into a multilateral format that would include Russia, but the next step remains unresolved. The latest diplomatic effort centres on whether representatives from Europe and Moscow can sit at the same table after months of parallel discussions. Russia, however, has cast doubt on the timing and scope of any direct meeting.
Yury Ushakov, a close aide to Russian President Vladimir Putin, said the date had not been agreed and that any expansion of the format had not been settled with Moscow. He also suggested that another round, or possibly more than one round, of trilateral talks involving the United States and Ukraine may be needed first. After speaking with Ushakov, US special envoy Jared Kushner said preparations were under way for a multilateral meeting that should take place in the near future.
The European side has now settled on a joint team to represent the continent in the negotiations. That delegation includes France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Italy, Poland, the European Union institutions and NATO. European officials have said they are ready to engage at the multilateral level, while privately warning that expectations should remain low because the talks remain volatile and Russia has not committed to a clear timetable.
The push matters because it marks a shift in how the main parties are trying to manage the war in Ukraine. Until now, the process has run along two parallel tracks: Ukraine, Russia and the United States on one side, and Ukraine, Europe and the United States on the other. That arrangement has left Europe outside the main room for much of the discussion, even as the war continues to shape European security and diplomacy.
The latest talks also reflect a broader effort to bring Europe and Russia into direct contact after years in which such engagement has been largely absent. Kushner said direct engagement was important so both sides could hear each other's concerns and proposals directly as work continues toward a more stable and secure future for Europe. European officials have indicated that the current format has reached its limit, but Moscow's position suggests the process may still require further preliminary rounds before any wider meeting can happen.
What remains unclear is when, or even whether, a direct multilateral meeting will take place. The date has not been agreed, and the format is still under discussion. The next developments to watch are whether further trilateral talks are held, whether Russia accepts the expanded format, and whether the European delegation is eventually brought into the same room as Moscow.

